HomeResponse to Motion to Exclude Unreliable Evidence (Post Mortem Banding) - 3/16/2011
2 posters
Page 1 of 1
Response to Motion to Exclude Unreliable Evidence (Post Mortem Banding) - 3/16/2011
by mom_in_il Wed Mar 16, 2011 6:47 pm
03/16/2011 . . . Response to Motion to Exclude Unreliable Evidence (Post Mortem Banding)
http://myclerk.myorangeclerk.com
http://myclerk.myorangeclerk.com
mom_in_il- Supreme Commander of the Universe With Cape AND Tights AND Fancy Headgear
Re: Response to Motion to Exclude Unreliable Evidence (Post Mortem Banding) - 3/16/2011
by The_Thinker Thu Mar 17, 2011 3:22 pm
THANK YOU WFTV FOR POSTING THIS MOTION
03/16/2011 . . . Response to Motion to Exclude Unreliable Evidence (Post Mortem Banding)
http://www.wftv.com/pdf/27218872/detail.html
378 pages
Footnote - page 1 - "In this case it is interesting to note that the hair in question was examined by an expert in this area hired by the Defense who, after his examination, she declined to list as a witness. [Nicholas Petraco] To date no defense witness is disputing the FBI analysts [FBI Trace Evidence Unit - Karen Korsberg Lowe ] opinion in this matter."
page 3-4 - "... The court concluded, based largely upon the testimony of Nicholas Petraco, and Dr. Peter DeForest, authors of the first referenced journal article above, "that the methodology testified to by the defendant's experts concerning postmortem hair banding is generally accepted within the forensic scientific community" at 378...."
"The State would also submit for the courts consideration a transcript of the testimony of Nicholas Petraco, and Dr. Peter DeForest in People v. Kogut. (Appendix D)."
Footnote - page 4 - "Mr. Petraco is, not coincidentally, the Defendant's expert referenced in footnote 1."
FBI Trace Evidence Unit - Karen Korsberg Lowe
https://docs.google.com/document/edit?id=1SJuT6ZnZa_DMbH7rK5QXMFWMCG9xV7KVoIjLLRZfg_E&hl=en
DEFENSE WITNESS LIST
Nicholas Petraco - New York - John Jay College of Criminal Justice
EXPERT - Criminalist and Hair Banding Expert - Forensic Science
He reviewed the evidence in July 2010, and was sent FBI samples Q12 and
Q12.1 hair in trunk - to examine in October 2010
Never officially placed on Defense Witness List - announced in
Nov 29, 2010 Status Hearing that he would not be a Defense Witness
http://www.wftv.com/news/20723700/detail.html
Padilla, Bodyguards Tell All In Newly Released Interviews
Posted: 9:19 am EDT September 4, 2009
excerpt
"Casey had an even colder reaction to the finding that hair consistent with hers and Caylee's came from a dead body."
"She goes, 'Well, I'm alive,'" McLaughlin told investigators."
[NOTE: Tracy McL is not on either the State nor Defense Witness List, and neither is L. Padilla or Rob D.]
03/16/2011 . . . Response to Motion to Exclude Unreliable Evidence (Post Mortem Banding)
http://www.wftv.com/pdf/27218872/detail.html
378 pages
Footnote - page 1 - "In this case it is interesting to note that the hair in question was examined by an expert in this area hired by the Defense who, after his examination, she declined to list as a witness. [Nicholas Petraco] To date no defense witness is disputing the FBI analysts [FBI Trace Evidence Unit - Karen Korsberg Lowe ] opinion in this matter."
page 3-4 - "... The court concluded, based largely upon the testimony of Nicholas Petraco, and Dr. Peter DeForest, authors of the first referenced journal article above, "that the methodology testified to by the defendant's experts concerning postmortem hair banding is generally accepted within the forensic scientific community" at 378...."
"The State would also submit for the courts consideration a transcript of the testimony of Nicholas Petraco, and Dr. Peter DeForest in People v. Kogut. (Appendix D)."
Footnote - page 4 - "Mr. Petraco is, not coincidentally, the Defendant's expert referenced in footnote 1."
FBI Trace Evidence Unit - Karen Korsberg Lowe
https://docs.google.com/document/edit?id=1SJuT6ZnZa_DMbH7rK5QXMFWMCG9xV7KVoIjLLRZfg_E&hl=en
DEFENSE WITNESS LIST
Nicholas Petraco - New York - John Jay College of Criminal Justice
EXPERT - Criminalist and Hair Banding Expert - Forensic Science
He reviewed the evidence in July 2010, and was sent FBI samples Q12 and
Q12.1 hair in trunk - to examine in October 2010
Never officially placed on Defense Witness List - announced in
Nov 29, 2010 Status Hearing that he would not be a Defense Witness
http://www.wftv.com/news/20723700/detail.html
Padilla, Bodyguards Tell All In Newly Released Interviews
Posted: 9:19 am EDT September 4, 2009
excerpt
"Casey had an even colder reaction to the finding that hair consistent with hers and Caylee's came from a dead body."
"She goes, 'Well, I'm alive,'" McLaughlin told investigators."
[NOTE: Tracy McL is not on either the State nor Defense Witness List, and neither is L. Padilla or Rob D.]
The_Thinker- Supreme Commander of the Universe With Cape AND Tights AND Fancy Headgear
- Job/hobbies : Dear Caylee**gone but not forgotten**
Similar topics» Order Denying Motion to Exclude Unreliable Evidence (Post Mortem Banding) and Unreliability of Scientific Testimony by Karen Lowe on Post-Mortem Hair Banding - 4/26/2011
» Court Minutes Defense Motion to Exclude Unreliable Evidence (Post Mortem Banding) - Court Reserved Ruling - 3/24/2011
» Court Minutes Court Heard Arguments on Defense Motion to Exclude Unreliable Evidence on Post Mortem Reserved Ruling - 4/8/2011
» Notice of Providing Appendix A for Purposes of Motion to Exclude Unreliable Evidence Pursuant to FRYE, or in the Alternative, Motion in Limine to Exclude (Chloroform) & Motion to Exclude Unreliable Evidence (Decompositional Chemical)(FRYE) - 4/4/2011
» Motion In Limine Amended; for Hearing on the Unreliability of Scientific Testimony by Karen Lowe on Post-Mortem Hair Banding - 3/29/2011
» Court Minutes Defense Motion to Exclude Unreliable Evidence (Post Mortem Banding) - Court Reserved Ruling - 3/24/2011
» Court Minutes Court Heard Arguments on Defense Motion to Exclude Unreliable Evidence on Post Mortem Reserved Ruling - 4/8/2011
» Notice of Providing Appendix A for Purposes of Motion to Exclude Unreliable Evidence Pursuant to FRYE, or in the Alternative, Motion in Limine to Exclude (Chloroform) & Motion to Exclude Unreliable Evidence (Decompositional Chemical)(FRYE) - 4/4/2011
» Motion In Limine Amended; for Hearing on the Unreliability of Scientific Testimony by Karen Lowe on Post-Mortem Hair Banding - 3/29/2011
Page 1 of 1
Permissions in this forum:
You cannot reply to topics in this forum